| Johnstown Lodge No. 538 |
| 1875 | | John P. Linton | |
| 1876 | | John P. Linton | |
| 1877 | | Daniel N. Jones | |
| 1878 | | James S. Galligher | |
| 1879 | | Thomas N. Nicholls | |
| 1880 | | Henry W. Storey | |
| 1881 | | Thomas N. Nicholls | |
| 1882 | | James N. Schumaker | |
| 1883 | | Adam S. Brubaker | |
| 1884 | | George E. Hamilton | |
| 1885 | | William F. Meyers | |
| 1886 | | John K. Lee | |
| 1887 | | Harry L. Coulter | |
| 1888 | | Harry L. Coulter | |
| 1889 | | William H. Overbeck | |
| 1890 | | Joseph G. Brown | |
| 1891 | | Anderson H. Walters | |
| 1892 | | Samuel B. Waters | |
| 1893 | | John K. Frye | |
| 1894 | | William Masterton | |
| 1895 | | Herbert C. Ryding | |
| 1896 | | Charles L. Morgan | |
| 1897 | | Clarence Bennett | |
| 1898 | | David H. Davies | |
| 1899 | | Charles A. Birk | |
| 1900 | | Levi J. Foust | |
| 1901 | | Charles H. Krauss | |
| 1902 | | George M. Harshberger | |
| 1903 | | Charles A. Matthews | |
| 1904 | | R. Given Rose | |
| 1905 | | Franklin D. Baker | |
| 1906 | | Curtis G. Campbell | |
| 1907 | | Kennedy W. Hamilton | |
| 1908 | | Thomas J. Harris | |
| 1909 | | Abner R. Bartley | |
| 1910 | | Harry B. Hershy | |
| 1911 | | W. Winston Davis | |
| 1912 | | William A. Reibe | |
| 1913 | | John F. Bowman | |
| 1914 | | Thomas D. Evans | |
| 1915 | | Harry W. Masters | |
| 1916 | | Otto Franke | |
| Johnstown Lodge No. 538 | | Conemaugh Valley Lodge No. 692 |
| 1917 | Harry M. Griffith | | James N. McKee |
| 1918 | Jackson R. Crissey | | James N. McKee |
| 1919 | Louis Franke | | Ernest G. Owen |
| 1920 | Irwin W. Penrod | | Hilliard B. Chronister |
| 1921 | John C. Slater | | William W. E. Moore |
| 1922 | Henry Lauer | | H. Lee Wilson |
| 1923 | Tillman K. Saylor | | Fr. M. B. Schramm |
| 1924 | Francis C. Martin | | Wesley J. Rose |
| 1925 | Clifford F. Bollinger | | Harry B. Miller |
| Johnstown Lodge No. 538 | Conemaugh Valley Lodge No. 692 | Sunnehanna Lodge No. 742 |
| 1926 | David M. Jenkins | George H. Fullmer | George W. Reese |
| 1927 | L. Harvey Mitchell | Elwood B. Murdock | Howard W. Stull |
| 1928 | James W. Lynam | William C. Hesselbein | Howard M. Picking, Sr. |
| 1929 | Louis K. Cleaver | Charles O. Launtz | Howard M. Picking, Sr. |
| 1930 | Harry C. Mansell | Robert W. Snook | Lester W. Dawson |
| 1931 | Andrew H. McClelland | Joseph J. Meyer | John Henneke |
| 1932 | Howard E. Bathurst | Donald H. Matthews | Stephen W. Ross |
| 1933 | Conrad Ruckser | James Killius | John C. Lowery, Jr. |
| 1934 | Edwin D. Lucas | Joseph E. Kuntz | Edgar W. Matthews |
| 1935 | Albert Humphreys | Ray Parker | Edward Zilker |
| 1936 | Ralph R. Willet | Walter T. Kenny | Clark Snowden |
| 1937 | Orland A. Kipp | Elmer R. Griffith | Benjamin S. Bowman |
| 1938 | Fred K. Frank | John O. Rettew | Lewis R. Burr |
| 1939 | Fred L. Barnhart | Irwin W. Shearer | Howard M. Picking, Jr. |
| 1940 | George A. Goebert | Dorsey L. Walker | Morris C. Fraint |
| 1941 | Harry W. Cassler | Harry F. Stetler | Alvin M. Berkey |
| 1942 | William F. Harper | Harold D. Rhode | Colbert W. Varner |
| 1943 | Kenneth K. Klahre | Harold M. Wilson | L. Z. Tomb |
| 1944 | Clyde W. Reighard | George J. Edkins | John C. Slater |
| 1945 | J. Homer Wonder | Daniel Ellis | J. Chalmer Layman |
| 1946 | Russell M. Berkey | Manuel Higgins | Howard W. Carston |
| 1947 | Theodore R. Wagner | Thomas J. Jones | Camden L. Imhoff, Jr. |
| 1948 | Chester E. McDonald | George C. Dunham | Homer H. Hoenstine |
| 1949 | Harold I. Meier | Charles L. Slagle | Ewart Roberts |
| 1950 | Harry W. Wagner | Elmer G. Walther | Theodore F. Zaintz |
| 1951 | Earl W. Deardorff | Sandord H. Sipe | Charles R. Rippen |
| 1952 | Morris E. Strayer, I | William H. Ewald | John F. Slater |
| 1953 | Delmar H. Boring | Harry J. Berkey, Jr. | Andrew R. Barr, Jr. |
| 1954 | Robert C. Rounsley | Donald E. Manges | William R. McMullen |
| 1955 | Algie T. Luther | Sanford J. Haney | Handel Roberts |
| 1956 | William M. Lauf | Clair L. Mowery | Frank W. Sievers |
| 1957 | William F. Horner | Paul G. Ulerich | Arthur E. Elliot |
| 1958 | Stanley B. Kocher | Herbert C. Croft | Walter G. Beals |
| 1959 | Wiliam F. Spires | Robert M. Schucker | Thoburn N. Houck |
| 1960 | Robert F. Ankeny | Jerome B. Collins | Wayne E. Robel |
| 1961 | Frederick G. Miller | Russell K. Shaffer | George W. Mandel |
| 1962 | Russell K. Edmond | George R. Paessler | Robert A. Fullerton |
| 1963 | H. Harton Roberts | John C. Schmidt | Freeman F. Fullerton, Jr. |
| 1964 | William J. Swank | Robert R. Havers, Sr. | G. Donald Ringler |
| 1965 | Harold L. Crum | Stanley W. Dunn | Charles J. Toothman |
| 1966 | Harold M. Hooper | Thomas Reed | Homer E. Roth |
| 1967 | Kenneth K. Shaffer | Harry E. Brazil | William A. Frye |
| 1968 | Thomas R. Adams | Raymond L. Snavely | Virgil G. Faust |
| 1969 | Charles F. Lind | John Hruska | Ira Tomb |
| 1970 | James K. Thompson | Frank R. Taggart, Jr. | H. William Marks |
| 1971 | Robert J. Brotemarkle | Robert F. Geisel | John D. Ream |
| 1972 | Fred D. Saintz | Thomas C. Ruckser | John Vonau, Jr. |
| 1973 | Ralph E. Mulhollen | George C. Penrod | Charles L. Glessner |
| 1974 | Thomas R. Adams | Robert W. Bender | Richard E. Orris |
| 1975 | Roy T. Marsh | A. Ronald Rice | Dennis L. Holtzman |
| 1976 | John J. Cafeo | George C. Penrod | Arthur N. Moore |
| 1977 | John M. Miller | Leonard W. McMillen | Francis J. Smith |
| 1978 | Charls M. Glass | Leonard W. McMillen | Joseph O. Wilkinson |
| 1979 | Charles G. Holsopple | Frederick C. Horner | Robert J. Kidd |
| 1980 | Evan T. Bennett | Frederick C. Horner | Robert J. Kidd |
| 1981 | Edward H. McGreehan | Edward J. Cernic, Jr. | Wendell M. Carter |
| 1982 | Charles Bulich | Edward J. Cernic, Jr. | Charles R. Glessner |
| 1983 | Horace J. Hubbard, II | Thomas C. Oyler | Duane C. Robb |
| 1984 | J. James Williams | Thomas C. Oyler | Timothy B. Fyock |
| 1985 | Thomas J. Hubbard | Roy I. King | David J. Rodge |
| 1986 | John C. Lucas | Fred R. Smith | Matthew J. Pozar |
| 1987 | Donald E. Heckler | Clarence C. Clark | Matthew J. Pozar |
| 1988 | Thomas J. Hubbard | Herbert W. Ewald | R. Scott Hagerich |
| 1989 | Robert H. Teeter | Herbert W. Ewald | R. Scott Hagerich |
| 1990 | David J. Rodgers | Robert W. Statler | Charles R. Glessner |
| 1991 | Peter Timko | Robert W. Statler | Dwight R. Carbaugh |
| Johnstown-Conemaugh Lodge No. 538 | | Sunnehanna Lodge No. 742 |
| 1992 | James S. Cover, Jr. | | James E. Lemmert |
| 1993 | Robert J. Matula | | James E. Lemmert |
| 1994 | Harold J. Crum | | William B. Smith |
| 1995 | Richard L. Griffiths | | Jay H. Eisenhauer |
| 1996 | Bradley E. McVicker | | Francis J. Smith |
| | Greater Johnstown Lodge No. 538 | |
| 1997 | | James R. Virgin | |
| 1998 | | Edward L. Langham, Jr. | |
| 1999 | | Michael E. Ondesko, Jr. | |
| 2000 | | Harold M. Wilson, Jr. | |
| 2001 | | Richard M. Smith | |
| 2002 | | Joseph C. Barrett | |
| 2003 | | Herbert W. Ewald | |
| 2004 | | Alvin E. Just | |
| 2005 | | Franklin D. Reffner | |
| 2006 | | Owen R. Hofecker, Jr. | |
| 2007 | | William J. Huston | |
| 2008 | | James F. Hockycko | |
| 2009 | | David A. Blackner | |
| 2010 | | Mark A. Adams, Jr. | |
| 2011 | | James K. Dreier | |
| 2012 | | James K. Dreier | |
| 2013 | | Jonathan A. Rutledge | |
| 2014 | | Loren W. Hauman | |
| 2015 | | Christopher L. Kantz | |
| 2016 | | Ricky L. Fetzer | |
| 2017 | | Ricky L. Fetzer | |
| 2018 | | Alan R. Lessig | |
| 2019 | | Alan R. Lessig | |
| 2020 | | Alan R. Lessig | |
| 2021 | | Jerry L. Wiesheier | |
| 2022 | | Christoper L. Watkins | |
| 2023 | | John E. MacEwan | |
| 2024 | | John E. MacEwan | |
| 2025 | | Brennen T. Stiffler | |
